Scientific Peer Review
Systematic process for evaluating scientific manuscripts with constructive, rigorous evaluation.
When to Use
- Conducting peer review of manuscripts for journals
- Evaluating grant proposals and research applications
- Assessing methodology and experimental design rigor
- Reviewing statistical analyses and reporting standards
- Evaluating reproducibility and data availability
- Checking compliance with reporting guidelines (CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA)
- Providing constructive feedback
Key Evaluation Areas
- Methodology: Experimental design, sample size, controls
- Statistics: Appropriate tests, power analysis, effect sizes
- Reproducibility: Data availability, code sharing, protocols
- Ethics: IRB approval, informed consent, conflicts of interest
- Reporting Standards: CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA compliance
Related Resource
The venue-templates skill provides reviewer expectations for different venues (Nature/Science, Cell Press, medical journals, ML conferences).
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Related Tools
Scientific Critical Thinking Skill
github.com/K-Dense-AI/claude-scientific-writer
Evaluate research rigor systematically - assess methodology, experimental design, statistical validity, biases, confounding, and evidence quality using GRADE and Cochrane ROB.
Scientific Writing Skill
github.com/K-Dense-AI/claude-scientific-writer
Core skill for writing research manuscripts in IMRAD structure with proper citations, figures, and reporting guidelines.
Literature Review Skill
github.com/K-Dense-AI/claude-scientific-writer
Conduct comprehensive systematic literature reviews across multiple academic databases with verified citations.
Related Insights
Skills + Hooks + Plugins: How Anthropic Redefined AI Coding Tool Extensibility
An in-depth analysis of Claude Code's trinity architecture of Skills, Hooks, and Plugins. Explore why this design is more advanced than GitHub Copilot and Cursor, and how it redefines AI coding tool extensibility through open standards.
Complete Guide to Claude Skills - 10 Essential Skills Explained
Deep dive into Claude Skills extension mechanism, detailed introduction to ten core skills and Obsidian integration to help you build an efficient AI workflow
Claude Code's Next Frontier: Not Code, But Your Local Obsidian Knowledge Base
Explore how Obsidian + Claude Code transforms from a knowledge management tool into your private AI assistant. Complete guide including obsidian-skills, Claudian plugin, Claudesidian template, and best practices for achieving both data privacy and AI capabilities.